Creation & Origins
Was There Death Before Adam Sinned?
Young-earth says no. Old-earth says yes. Romans 5:12 is the battleground.
Here's the article:
Depends on who you ask — and both sides have legit arguments from Scripture. This is one of those questions where faithful, Bible-believing Christians have been going back and forth for centuries, so buckle up. The short version: say zero existed before ate the fruit — not animals, not plants, nothing. Old-earth creationists say that's reading too much into it, and that point in is specifically about spiritual death. The fossil record showing hundreds of millions of years of animal death is what makes this more than just a theological theory battle.